Sirianni’s Pizza Cafe - Authentic Italian Dining in Davis, WV

A friend and I were doing some hiking in Monongahela National Forest for several days. On October 22, 2025, we decided to give Sirianni's Café a go. Before you even open the door, the delicious smells of the food hits you. We got there around 5:30PM and when we left at around 7:00ish the place was comfortably packed. The service was outstanding, friendly and attentive. We each had the pizza but all the other food looked really good as well. The pie was “off-the-charts-on-point”, and the sauce and crust were amazing. Paired with locally brewed amber ale, the meal was top notch. Hands down some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Great selection of wine as well! I’d highly recommend this restaurant if you’re in the area or even not so close by. Note though, it’s cash only but they do have an ATM on site.

The best pizza around had the most amazing time with my family I highly recommend if you are in the area

We came by on a Friday night around an hour before closing. Very lively! Beautiful restaurant, that has a really cozy welcoming energy to it. We didn’t try anything but the pizza, but it was incredible. Top 10 pizza’s we’ve ever tried.

Pasta and pizza was share by our group of 7. All were pronounced “excellent”. Eclectic decor with posters of everything from Alf Landon to Rio de Janeiro. Our most wine savvy couple loved the wine list. Pleasantly surprised that this tiny venue in a small town is such a great place.

A local classic, been around since 1988!! There can be a short wait so plan accordingly. As everyone else mentioned, yes it's cash only, with an ATM inside. We ordered the garlic chips, a pasta and a medium pizza for two. So much food! The portions are enormous. The pasta was good but felt under seasoned. Garlic chips were perfect and mega garlicky. The interior is cozy and comfortable. Our server must have been new because she didn't know the menu, and was a bit slow and forgetful, took quite a while to bring things out.

Yum. Simple and straight--yum. We had a cheese pizza because that's the real test. You can't hide good or bad pizza when it's just crust, sauce, cheese. All were great. We also got a mushroom, lemon linguini. We added more fresh lemon to it and it was delicious, too. I had a cabernet that was smooth and fine for the little bottles they sell. Highly recommended in this lovely area. Cash only so be prepared for that.

We went down to Sirianni's Café for a late lunch after getting massages at the Canaan Valley Spa and Wellness Center. We ordered a bottle of wine, stuffed peppers, and a meatball hoagie. The service was excellent and employees very polite. The stuffed peppers were slightly spicy, which was exactly what we wanted. The meatball hoagie was large (and we split it) and full of tasty meatballs and a very Italian tasting red sauce. What a great day!

This is such a good place. I loved everything I ate, the workers were so sweet and the atmosphere is such a cool vibe. Everything is fairly priced, as compared to the lodges around town. I can’t speak highly enough of the quality of food and people. The stuffed peppers are to die for btw(no pic cause they were eaten so quickly lol)